Menu of Gemelli's Gourmet LI in Lindenhurst, New York, USA

Menu Overview

Gemelli's Gourmet LI, located at 189 S Wellwood Ave in Lindenhurst, NY, is a remarkable culinary gem that redefines the deli experience with its authentic Italian flair and gourmet craftsmanship. From the moment you step inside, the inviting atmosphere and attentive, friendly staff set the tone for an exceptional dining adventure that feels both warm and sophisticated.

The menu is a masterclass in thoughtful ingredient pairing and quality. Their all-day sandwiches stand out, particularly the Stracci Chachi, featuring a breaded chicken cutlet, prosciutto di Parma, and luscious stracciatella cheese, layered with arugula, sun-dried tomatoes, and a drizzle of hot honey that delivers a beautifully balanced sweet-heat profile on a fresh hero roll. Equally impressive, the Gemina sandwich combines an array of Italian cured meats—Genoa salami, mortadella, prosciutto di Parma—to create a rich, savory depth, all brought together with provolone, fresh mozzarella, and a house vinaigrette that adds just the right splash of acidity and brightness.

For burger enthusiasts, the Meatball Burger is a revelation. It offers juicy, well-seasoned meatballs nestled in a brioche bun, topped with provolone, fresh tomato, spinach, and a basil-garlic aioli that elevates each bite. The side of crispy onion rings with tangy remoulade is a perfect complement, adding texture and zest to the meal.

The salad selection reveals a keen eye for freshness and balance. The Beet & Apple Salad pairs peppery arugula with sweet beets, crisp apples, pecans, and creamy goat cheese, all tied together with a balsamic vinaigrette that is both tart and smooth. The Balsamic Chicken Salad boasts succulent grilled chicken over a bed of baby spinach, olives, cherry tomatoes, shredded mozzarella, and a generous drizzle of balsamic dressing, crystallizing Gemelli’s talent for combining hearty proteins with crisp greens and vibrant accents.

The glowing rave reviews from patrons underscore Gemelli's commitment to excellence. One customer’s praise for the Po Boy sandwich—cited as surpassing authentic New Orleans versions—is a testament to the kitchen’s meticulous technique: perfectly cooked shrimp and a precisely balanced sauce that bursts with flavor without overwhelming the palate. The farfalle pasta with broccoli, garlic, and oil also merits special mention for being "super garlicky" and arriving piping hot, a sign of genuine care in preparation and delivery.

Pasadena’s clean, well-kept space reflects the careful attention embedded in every facet of the operation—from the spotless counters to the thoughtfully organized displays—making it an ideal spot for both dining in and takeout. The staff’s consistent warmth creates a welcoming vibe, elevating the entire experience.

In summary, Gemelli’s Gourmet LI is a standout destination that harmonizes premium ingredients, artful flavor combinations, and exceptional service. It’s a go-to for connoisseurs craving artisan sandwiches, inventive salads, and flavorful burgers, all served within an atmosphere that invites you to savor every bite. Whether you’re stopping by for a satisfying lunch or planning a special occasion order, Gemelli’s delivers unparalleled quality that keeps customers coming back time and again.